Home About Us Vintjärn Flies and Fishing Friends



Fly fishing is in its elementary form quite easy. In less than an hour, a beginner will be able to make a cast of about 15 meters and with a bit of luck catch his first fish on the fly. But which fly? As a young man, I once visited a stream after having read an article by a renowned fishing writer. The particular fly he regarded as essential was complicated to tie, and since the material was hard to come by, I had to go without. With no real hope, I made my first cast. And quite unexpectedly my rod bent over and a fish came bouncing across the stream, well hooked and with lots of fighting spirit. The rest of my week at the stream turned into a triumph. I caught fish every day, met lots of nice people who also caught fish every day and I left by the end of the week with minimal faith in experts and their advices, After an experience like this it is easy to reach the conclusion that it does not matter which fly you use. That is not true, of course.






It is an undeniable fact that certain fishermen normally catch more fish than others. Not many more, perhaps two or three a day. The reasons for that are several, but the choice of fly is important, sometimes absolutely essential. Not all successful flies are born out of a logical thought, but quite often, there is a well-founded idea behind the pattern. This is the story of the first Muddler.




In 1948, Don Gapen guide and fly tier from Anoka, Minnesota, was on a fishing trip in Canada. The place was Nipigon River in the state of Ontario. One night, walking along the river, he met a group of Indians of the Ojibway tribe. They carried lanterns, and asked about their errand they explained that they were after a certain fish to use for bait.




Paralyzed by the strong light the tiny creatures were speared with the help of ordinary table forks. One of the Indians showed his catch, a little bullhead named Muddler by the locals. The best bait for big trout, he claimed. The bullhead in the picture is for obvious reasons not from Nipigon River, but from one of my woodland streams.



Don asked for a specimen and returning home, he placed the fish on his workbench in order to create an imitation. For the big head, he chose body fur from deer that gave the volume he wanted to attain. The world's first Muddler was bushy creation with a rather crude head and a wing where two sections of turkey feather sections encircled a bunch of straggling wolf’s hair.



In spite of the peculiar appearance, the fly was a success from the start. Don Gapen found that it not only had a strong attraction to fish of the salmon species. Also bass, walleye, pike, grayling and divers types of so-called sunfish responded to the pattern. Even salt-water fish like snook, bonefish, bonito and shark were caught on Muddlers.




Within a short time, the Muddler became enormously popular in the US, but it took a long time before it was appreciated in Sweden. When Nils Färnström, in the beginning of the 1960's, made a fishing trip to Kashmir he was advised by his “shikaris” to use a Muddler, which they regarded almost infallible. That same year Nils, with no intention to use them for fishing, had bought a few Muddlers mostly as curios.





From the birth at shores of Nipigon River, the Muddler family has grown continually. Hundreds of variants, more and less successful, have seen the light of day. The one thing they all have in common is the trimmed head made of deer hair. In different sizes, a Muddler probably can represent a whole lot of edibles. Under the surface small fry or large nymphs, on the surface grasshoppers or big sedges (caddies).  




The Muddler, originally aimed at imitating a bottom-hugging bullhead, is nowadays often used as a top water attractor fly. It is especially popular at our put-and-take fisheries. Slowly slided along a smooth water surface the Muddler has a great ability to induce takes from sluggish trout or rainbows on a warm summer’s evening.



My own favorite Muddler has few similarities with Don Gapen’s original. The body is flat golden tinsel, the head is deer hair and tail and wing are hairs from Swedish or Siberian squirrel’s tail. For practical reasons I mostly use squirrel’s tail hairs for my Muddlers instead of the rather delicate turkey feather sections.



This is a stream section well suited for fishing the Muddler. Fished down and across, slided over smother water between white-water necks, it is sometimes very effective. Your answer has to be fast, since the take is usually indicated only by a glimpse.




Fishing a Muddler is exciting. The take is violent and most of the time unexpected, since there are no rises and other signs that fish are around. I am sure that many a fly fisherman has regretted not having exchanged his leader for a stronger one.  




This lovely trout fell for my Muddler towards evening after blank day. Judged by its shape he has had a good life in his restricted environment, a dark pool shaded by a dense pine forest.  




A Muddler, which unlike the previous ones always is used as a subsurface fly. It is called Spuddler and has a conical head for easy entrance into the water. The wing consists of two cock hackle feathers, the dull sides against each other with a thin bunch of squirrel’s tail hair in between.




Dahlberg’s Diver, not exactly a Muddler but related to the Spuddler. The head is trimmed into a half cone, sporting a collar which makes the fly dive when you give it a sharp tug. I use this fly exclusively for pike.




Here is a salmon fly pattern I got from Erling Olsen, Norwegian fly tier and writer. Hook: LW, double or Mustad limerick 1/0 – 2. Tail: Pheasant feather fibers. Ribbing: Oval tinsel, Veniard size 15 silver. Underwing: Brown squirrel’s tail hairs mixed with a bunch of pheasant feather fibers and Lureflash, silver. Head/wing: Grey or brown deer hair.



Deer hair is often used as a group name for many types of hairs, all with their own characteristics. Personally, I like to use a domestic material for my Muddlers, namely winter pelt from raw-deer. A cheap material especially if you have a hunter among your friends. A layer of salt on the raw side of the pelt, two days to dry and material for hundreds of Muddlers is ready.




In my old fishing diary I read: ” Everything was against me. Intensely cold, water much too high. Time and time again my flies drifted past spots known to hold fish. Nothing. Ready to give up I tied on a Muddler. It floated like a cork, danced across the rippling waves on its way to the shore and all of a sudden the stream came alive. Fish after fish shot up snatching for the fly….” Happy Muddler fishing!


Home About Us Vintjärn Flies and Fishing Friends